Tax Filing Services•15 Min Free Call

Quick consultation to discuss your tax needs

LLC vs S Corp: Taxes, Pros and Cons, and C Corp Compared

Updated · 11 min read · By the Micahguru team · Checked against official sources

An LLC and an S corp are not two kinds of company to pick between: an LLC is a legal entity created under state law, and an S corporation is a federal tax status, so an LLC can elect to be taxed as an S corporation. The real question is whether your LLC keeps its default tax treatment or files the election. This guide is written for US residents and covers who can elect, how, and what changes afterward, using only what the IRS publishes.

Key takeaways

  • An LLC is an entity created by state statute. S corporation status is a federal tax election made with the IRS.
  • A qualifying LLC elects S corporation status with Form 2553, signed by all the shareholders.
  • The IRS allows no more than 100 shareholders, one class of stock and no non resident alien shareholders.
  • After the election the LLC files Form 1120-S, and an owner who works in the business is paid wages through payroll.
  • The IRS says reasonable compensation must be paid before non wage distributions to an owner who works in the business.

What is the difference between an LLC and an S corp?

An LLC is an entity created by state statute, formed by a filing with a state. An S corporation is a tax classification: the IRS describes S corporations as corporations that elect to pass corporate income, losses, deductions and credits through to their shareholders for federal tax purposes. One is a legal form and the other is a way of being taxed, so the same business can be both.

By default the IRS does not tax an LLC as a corporation at all. An LLC with one member is treated as a disregarded entity, which means it is not separate from its owner for income tax. A domestic LLC with at least two members is classified as a partnership and files Form 1065. Either kind can choose a different classification: with an S corporation election the LLC files Form 1120-S, and with a C corporation election it files Form 1120.

None of these choices changes the state filing or your Operating Agreement. For the default rules, read how is an LLC taxed.

Who can elect S corp status, and how do you do it?

An LLC can elect S corporation status only if it meets every IRS test, and it makes the election by filing Form 2553, Election by a Small Business Corporation, signed by all the shareholders. The Form 2553 instructions say an eligible entity that files it on time is treated as a corporation from the effective date and does not need to file Form 8832 as well.

  • It is a domestic corporation, or a domestic entity eligible to elect to be treated as a corporation, which includes a US LLC.
  • It has only allowable shareholders. They may be individuals, certain trusts and estates. They may not be partnerships, corporations or non resident alien shareholders.
  • It has no more than 100 shareholders. The Form 2553 instructions let you count an individual and their spouse as one shareholder for this test.
  • It has only one class of stock. The instructions disregard differences in voting rights.
  • It is not an ineligible corporation, such as certain financial institutions, insurance companies and domestic international sales corporations.
  1. 1

    Check every owner against the tests

    The tests apply to every owner of the LLC. One owner who is not allowable, such as a partnership or a non resident alien, means the LLC does not qualify.

  2. 2

    Work out the filing window

    The Form 2553 instructions say to file no more than 2 months and 15 days after the beginning of the tax year the election is to take effect, or at any time during the tax year before it.

  3. 3

    File Form 2553 with every signature

    The IRS says the form must be signed by all the shareholders. The instructions for the form list where to file it.

  4. 4

    Start payroll for owners who work in the business

    The IRS chart for S corporations lists employment taxes on Form 941 and federal unemployment tax on Form 940, so wages paid to an owner run through payroll.

In the IRS examples, a calendar year business with a prior tax year that wants the election from January 1 has until March 15 of that year, and a new business whose first tax year begins January 7 has from January 7 to March 21. The instructions also describe relief for a late election when the business can show reasonable cause.

LLC vs S corp taxes: what changes after the election?

Three things change: the LLC files its own return on Form 1120-S, each owner reports their share of income from a Schedule K-1, and an owner who works in the business becomes an employee who is paid wages through payroll. The profit still passes through to the owners, who are taxed at their individual income tax rates.

  • Form 1120-S: the yearly income tax return of the S corporation, filed in place of the default LLC reporting.
  • Schedule K-1 (Form 1120-S): each owner reports their pro rata share of income, credits and deductions, on Form 1040 with Schedule E.
  • Form 941: the quarterly return for Social Security and Medicare taxes and income tax withheld from wages. The IRS chart also lists Form 940 for federal unemployment tax.
  • Form W-2: the wage statement for wages paid, including to an owner.
  • Form 1040-ES: the IRS chart for S corporation shareholders lists it for estimated tax on their own returns.

On pay, the IRS is direct. It says S corporations must pay reasonable compensation to a shareholder who is also an employee, in return for the services that person provides, before non wage distributions may be made to them. It also quotes the Form 1120-S instructions: distributions and other payments to a corporate officer must be treated as wages to the extent the amounts are reasonable compensation for services rendered to the corporation.

The IRS does not publish a fixed figure or percentage for reasonable compensation. It looks at what the owner did for the business and lists factors such as training and experience, duties and responsibilities, time and effort devoted to the business, payments to employees who are not shareholders, and what comparable businesses pay for similar services.

The common mistake is taking money out as distributions while paying little or no wages. The IRS says it has the authority to reclassify payments made to shareholders from non wage distributions to wages, which are subject to employment taxes, and it lists court cases that support this.

How does self employment tax compare with S corp wages?

In a default LLC the owner pays self employment tax on net earnings from the business. In an LLC taxed as an S corporation the owner who works in the business is paid wages, and Social Security and Medicare taxes are withheld from those wages and matched by the company. The rates are the same in total; what differs is the amount they apply to.

  • Default LLC: the IRS lists the self employment tax rate as 15.3%, made up of 12.4% for Social Security and 2.9% for Medicare. The owner figures it on Schedule SE with Form 1040.
  • S corporation wages: the IRS lists Social Security at 6.2% for the employer and 6.2% for the employee, or 12.4% in total, and Medicare at 1.45% each, or 2.9% in total.
  • Limit: for 2026 the Social Security part stops at $184,500 of wages or combined earnings. Medicare has no wage base limit.
  • Additional Medicare Tax: 0.9% applies to wages and self employment income above a threshold set by filing status, for example $200,000 for a single filer.

The IRS describes non wage distributions from an S corporation as not subject to employment taxes, and that is the difference most comparisons point to. The same IRS page ties it to the reasonable compensation rule above. This guide does not give an income level at which the election pays for itself, because the IRS does not publish one. The default rules are in self employment tax for an LLC.

LLC vs S corp vs C corp: how do they compare?

A default LLC and an LLC taxed as an S corporation both pass profit through to the owners, while a C corporation is a separate taxpaying entity. The IRS says the profit of a C corporation is taxed to the corporation when earned and then taxed to the shareholders when distributed as dividends, which it calls a double tax.

PointDefault LLCLLC taxed as S corpC corp
How it is chosenNothing to file with the IRSForm 2553, signed by all shareholdersFor an LLC, Form 8832
Who can own itSet by state lawNo more than 100 shareholders, only allowable shareholders, one class of stockThe S corporation tests do not apply
Business returnNone for one member, whose return carries it; Form 1065 for two or moreForm 1120-SForm 1120
Who pays income taxThe owners, on their own returnsThe owners, on their own returnsThe corporation, and shareholders again when profit is paid out as dividends
Owner who works in the businessSelf employment tax on net earningsWages through payroll, with reasonable compensationWages, with employment taxes on them
Payroll returns for owner payNot for the owner; only if the LLC has employeesForms 941 and 940, and Form W-2Forms 941 and 940

The IRS adds that shareholders cannot deduct a loss of a C corporation. The full comparison is in LLC vs C corp. If you have not formed a company yet, start with LLC vs sole proprietorship.

S corp vs LLC for a small business: what are the pros and cons?

The default LLC is simpler, and the S corporation election adds work in exchange for a different split between wages and distributions. What a reader weighs is the extra cost of running payroll and filing a separate business return against how the two treat the owner's pay.

  • Default LLC, pro: no election to file, and a one member LLC has no separate federal income tax return.
  • Default LLC, con: the owner is subject to self employment tax on net earnings from the business.
  • S corp election, pro: profit still passes through, and non wage distributions are described by the IRS as not subject to employment taxes.
  • S corp election, con: payroll for the owner (Forms 941, 940 and W-2) and a separate return on Form 1120-S every year.
  • S corp election, con: ownership limits, so an investor that is a company or a non resident alien cannot become an owner while the election is in place.

Forming the LLC comes first either way. With Micahguru the LLC filing service is $0 plus the state fee. A US resident can stop there by using their own address in the state as registered agent and getting the EIN free at IRS.gov. The optional done for you services are a registered agent at $99 the first year and $49.50 a year after, the EIN at $49 with an SSN or ITIN, and annual report filing at $49 a year plus the state fee. If you want the returns prepared for you, our tax service covers federal and state filing.

Form the LLC first

We file your Articles of Organization for $0 plus the state fee and include a free Operating Agreement. The S corp election is a separate IRS filing you can make once the LLC exists.

Get started

Founders outside the US: an S corporation may not have non resident alien shareholders, so this election is not open to you. Read S corp for non residents for the options that are.

Frequently asked questions

Sources

This guide is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules, fees and IRS contact details change, so check the official source or ask a professional for your situation.

More guides

Skip the paperwork, we file it for you

LLC filing for $0 plus the state fee. Founders abroad get the registered agent and an EIN without an SSN for $179.